Leg Press vs Squat: Pros & Cons (+ Variations)

Here are some benefits of leg presses:

• The leg press, compared to the squat, is a great beginner exercise to work the lower body muscles.
• The leg press can effectively strengthen leg muscles without needing a spotter.
• Less range of motion than a squat leads to increased emphasis on the quads rather than the glutes and hamstrings.
• Adjusting the foot position on the footpads allows for emphasizing different muscles.
• It is easy to adjust the weight on a leg press machine.
• There is minimal load on the spine, making it a good exercise for individuals with back problems.

Leg Press Cons

Here are some downsides associated with leg presses:

• Injuries to your knees are possible if you lift too much weight or lock your knees when extending your legs.
• When using a leg press machine, the risk of working one leg harder than the other is present because the machine moves the same whether one or two legs are involved.
• It is possible to round your back if you are attempting to lift too much weight on the machine.
• It is essential to be mindful when loading the machine, as it may be tempting to add too much weight.

There aren’t many leg press variations as leg press machines limit options, but here are the common ones I use with my clients:

• One-Leg Leg Press: You can do the conventional leg press with a single leg for a more thorough workout. It is important to ensure the weight is manageable when using one leg during leg pressing.
• Higher Foot Placement of Leg Press: Feet placed higher on the footpad increase the extension and contraction of the hamstrings and glute muscles. There is a reduced range of motion at the knee during the leg press.
• Lower Foot Placement: Feet placed lower on the footpad require more effort from the quads and less hamstring and glute activation. This variation increases the range of motion of the knees.

Here are some benefits of squats:

• Squats target a range of muscles from different angles.
• Doing squats can help strengthen the core and back muscles.
• Squats may improve flexibility in the knees.
• It is an excellent exercise to increase leg strength.
• Squatting can help improve posture by focusing on keeping the back straight.

Squat Cons

Here are some disadvantages associated with squats:

• Risk of back injury when leaning too far forward or rounding the back.
• Shoulder strain is possible when supporting heavy barbells.
• Chance of getting stuck at the bottom of a squat and unable to get back up.
• Knee injuries can occur if they move too far in or out during the exercise.
• A spotter may be necessary, depending on the variation.

Many squat variations are available to help target upper body and leg muscles at different angles.

I consistently advise my clients to first master the standard squat technique, ensuring a solid foundation, before progressing to more advanced variations:

• Goblet Squats: Great for beginners, goblet squats with a chest-level kettlebell teach proper form and prep you for tougher moves like barbell squats.
• Barbell Squats: Load the bar on your upper back, keep straight, and squat. Remember, no leaning forward to avoid back strain.
• Hack Squats: Done with barbells or machines, hack squats are easier on your lower back as the weight aligns with your center of mass.
• Front Squat: Holding a barbell or dumbbells at shoulder height, front squats are knee-friendly and lower back safe.
• Wall Squat: Perfect for newbies or if you've got knee issues, wall squats are all about squatting against a wall until your thighs are parallel to the floor.
• Jump Squats: Squat down, then leap up; these are your go-to for an explosive leg workout.
• Pistol Squat: A one-leg challenge, pistol squats boost individual leg strength, core intensity, flexibility, and balance.

Pick one based on your fitness goals and abilities.

Leg presses, ideal for those with balance issues, are done seated and, as per the Frontiers in Sports and Active Living journal, allow deeper knee flexion and more force [2].

Squats, in contrast, engage your entire body, especially the core, enhancing overall strength and notably boosting jump performance, with a 12.4% increase in standard jumps and 12% in countermovement jumps, as detailed in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research [3].

Why not mix it up?

Using both leg presses and squats in your routine targets similar muscles in varied ways, maximizing benefits. It's the principle I often use with my clients.

I also recommend incorporating one of the high-quality protein powders we extensively tested into your fitness routine.