Total Shape is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

How to Make Protein Ice Cream
Homemade Recipes That Taste Amazing

Protein ice cream recipe Featured
Written by Connor Sellers
Last Updated on
0 Shares

Getting your protein fix doesn’t have to be done with mountains of meat or by downing the same protein shake every morning.

There are lots of healthy and delicious recipes out there that are high in nutrition and low in calories, and what better way to get your protein than to mix it into your ice cream?

If there is one food I will never EVER get sick of, it is ice cream. If that means I need to incorporate it multiple times a day in various disguises, you bet I will do it…especially if it means replacing my post workout protein shake with it.

Arman Liew Chef and Healthy Living Expert

Here is a selection of some of the most delicious protein ice cream recipes for you to try at home.

1. ​Protein Ice Cream (Paleo, Vegan, & Gluten-Free) 

This is one the healthiest protein ice cream recipes is incredibly simple and straightforward to make.

​With just three ​things blended and frozen, you'll have a healthy ice cream that's vegan, paleo, gluten-free, ​and not reliant on sugar for flavor.

Any blender or your regular food processor can be used to mix the ingredients; you don’t need an ice cream maker or any expensive equipment at all, just a big enough dish as it’s so tasty you’ll want to make it in bulk.

Healthy No Churn Workout Protein Ice Cream

Ingredients

  •  2 cans of 14 oz full-fat coconut milk
  • 1-4 scoops of your favorite protein powder (32-34 grams per scoop)
  • ½ cup Medjool dates
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract (optional)

Instructions

  • 1
    Place a deep dish pan or container into the freezer
  • 2
    In a blender pour in the chilled coconut milk and blend until creamy
  • 3
    Add in the Medjool dates and protein powder and continue blending until a thick and creamy texture
  • 4
    Transfer the protein ice cream mix into the pan and put back into the freezer
  • 5
    For the first hour make sure to stir the mixture every 20-30 minutes to avoid the ice cream becoming too crystalized
  • 6
    Thaw for 10-15 minutes before eating. Wet your ice cream scoop to allow easy transfer into a bowl

Nutrition

Each serving should be about 67 calories, and the protein content will vary depending on how much powder you use.

​Check this website for the recipe credit: The Big Mans World 

2. Blueberry Mango Protein Ice Cream

 If you’re feeling a little fruity, then using actual fruits is a great way to up the nutrition and flavor of a healthy protein ice cream recipe.

This blueberry mango ice cream is big on flavor and low in calories with a delicious creamy texture. Eat it pre or post workout for a quick and yummy protein fix.

The ingredients listed make for a single serving that is ready as soon as it comes out of the blender. If you want less, just tweak the recipe to taste and desired calorie content.

Blueberry Mango Protein Ice Cream

Ingredients

  • 1 cup or 140g of frozen blueberries
  • 1 cup or 140g of frozen mango chunks
  • 1 scoop of your chosen vanilla protein powder
  • ½ cup of unsweetened almond milk

Instructions

  • 1
    Add the chilled milk into the blender
  • 2
    Add in your fruit and protein powder
  • 3
    Blend until smooth and with a creamy texture
  • 4
    Serve and enjoy

The recipe and ingredients are simple, and there is lots of room to tweak it in terms of flavor and consistency. Play with it yourself.  

Nutrition

This makes one large serving with 305 calories and however much protein you put in there. If adding more protein powder, just add a little more liquid and fruit to balance it out.

​​​​​​​​Recipe from this website: ​Mugs For Muscles

3. Peanut Butter Cup Protein Ice Cream

Peanut Butter is not only a delicious treat for any time of the day but is also a little protein punch itself, which makes it an ideal flavor to base a protein ice cream around.

The combination of peanut butter, banana, and chocolate balances the salty with the sweet just perfectly, and makes for a healthy snack that doesn’t hold back on flavor or nutrition.

Peanut Butter Cup Protein Ice Cream

Ingredients

  • 2 scoops chocolate protein powder
  • 1 tbsp unsweetened cacao powder
  • 6 tbsp unsweetened almond milk
  • 4 tbsp all-natural peanut butter or almond butter
  • 4 medium frozen chopped bananas

Instructions

  • 1
    Combine the powder and liquid first in a separate bowl and stir until completely combined with a smooth consistency.
  • 2
    Pour the mixture into a blender and add the bananas and peanut butter.
  • 3
    Mix well until a thick creamy consistency is achieved.
  • 4
    Serve immediately and enjoy it.

Nutrition

This recipe is intended to make about 4 servings, and you can freeze the remainder for a chocolate and banana flavored treat at a later date. Each serving should typically provide around 237 calories and 10g of protein, but you can tweak this yourself further by modifying the ingredients. Adding any fruit or flavoring of your choice should work alright.

Recipe credit: Clean Food Crush 

4. Apricot Protein Ice Cream

By a matter of chance, all the ice cream so far has been accidentally vegan, as long as you’re not using whey or casein, at least. 

So here’s one for you cream heads out there that is full throttle moo milk - another perfectly simple recipe with just 4 ingredients, all whole foods that are healthy and delicious.

The apricot flavor really pops out of the yogurt to create a moreish and great tasting treat.

Apricot Protein Ice Cream

Ingredients

  • 1 500g tub of 2% Total Greek Yoghurt
  • ½ cup of vanilla whey protein powder
  • ⅛ cup of coconut sugar
  • 2 fresh apricots

Instructions

  • 1
    Place all of the ingredients into a blender and mix vigorously until a smooth and creamy consistency is achieved.
  • 2
    Pour the mixture into a shallow container to allow for even freezing.
  • 3
    Pop in the freezer for around 40 minutes.
  • 4
    Take it out and churn it to break up any ice crystals. Repeat this process until the desired consistency is achieved. (Churning at 40-minute intervals)
  • 5
    Enjoy.

Nutrition

This recipe should yield three servings all of about 217 calories for 25g of protein. You can substitute in a full-fat yogurt, but it will add calories, obviously. 

Recipe credit: Protein Pow

​5. ​PB ​Ice Cream by IFBB Pro Arash Rahbar

​Check out this video by IFBB Pro Arash Rahbar for another tasty ​dessert ...

What Protein Powder Should I Use For My Protein Ice Cream?

When it comes to choosing the perfect protein powder for your protein ice cream, it depends on taste and how well it mixes. My personal choice would be Transparent Labs Rice & Pea Protein Powder for a couple of reasons.

The first is that it tastes great and if you opt for the vanilla flavor you can easily achieve chocolate heaven by adding some cocoa powder yourself, but you can’t get vanilla back from chocolate. Versatile.

The second reason is that the rice and pea blend just seems to blend effortlessly smoothly every time I’ve used it.

​Try it out for yourself or use the recipes with your favorite powders and let us know how it goes.

Make sure to check out our ​high-protein donut recipe and our high-protein waffle recipe

About the author

Connor Sellers

Connor Sellers is a personal trainer and senior coach at Total Shape. His mission is to inspire people to relentlessly pursue their fitness and lifestyle goals. He believes staying fit has an overall positive effect on one’s body, mind, and spirit. Read more about him here​.

>