Total Shape is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Tasting Vanilla Protein Powder – Buyer’s Guide

Best tasting vanilla protein powder Featured
Written by Connor Sellers
Last Updated on
0 Shares

Vanilla is one of the most popular flavors for everything for a good reason. It has a rich smell and taste. 

It’s no surprise that ​for ​many protein powders, vanilla tastes a little different. Some of them can’t seem to get the flavor right. It’s either too sweet or too bland.

I took the time to try out some popular protein powder vanilla flavored to find the best one. Here is what I discovered about the best vanilla protein powder in the market.

Our ​Top Tasting vanilla Protein Powders

Product

Supplement Facts​

Key Highlights

Ora Organic Vegan Protein

#1 ​Ora Organic (Editor's Choice)

  • 22g Protein
  • ​2 Servings of Greens

  • 5g Net Carbs
  • Vegan-friendly
  • USDA Organic
  • Complete protein
  • BEST PRICE until the end of March
Transparent Labs ProteinSeries

​#2 ​Transparent Labs

  • 28g Protein
  • ​120 Calories

  • ​1g Carbs
  • 100% grass-fed cows are used
  • Contains immune system boosters
  • Lots of protein despite being whey protein concentrate
Legion Whey+ Protein

#3 ​Legion Whey+

  • 22g Protein
  • ​100 Calories

  • ​2g Carbs
  • Uses whey isolate protein
  • Non-GMO
  • No hormones, fillers, or unnecessary ingredients
BSN SYNTHA-6 Whey Protein Powder

#4 BSN SYNTHA-6  ​

  • 22g Protein
  • ​200 Calories

  • ​15g Carbs
  • Sweet flavor
  • Lots of protein sources
  • Tastes great even if you only add water
Muscle Pharm Combat Protein Powder

#5 ​MusclePharm

  • 25g Protein
  • ​130 Calories

  • ​1.5g Carbs
  • 5 different protein sources
  • Informed-Choice certified
  • Affordable option

1. Ora Organic Vegan Protein Powder (Editor's Choice)

Ora has a unique vegan protein powder available. ​This product has not one, not two, but THREE protein sources; rice, pea, and hemp.

On top of that, it has over 20 high-quality organic superfoods to help support your cognitive function and muscle function.

Their vanilla flavor gets lots of rave reviews for having a clean taste. I only mix it with water, and it tastes great.

Ora Organic Vegan Protein

PROS

  • Vegan-friendly
  • USDA Organic
  • Complete protein

CONS

  • A little gritty texture if you don’t shake well

​You can’t go wrong with their other two flavors though; Chocolate and Vanilla Chai are delicious in their own right.

This one is considered one of the best protein powders in the vegan community.

I have been searching to find a plant-based protein powder that was tasty and not chalky. This powder passed the test! - Gayla W, Ora User


2 - Transparent Labs Protein Series Grass Fed Whey

This whey protein powder is ​the isolate version. Usually, this means that the protein content is ​higher than a concentrate, ​with 24 grams of protein ​for every scoop. You can get plenty of quality protein from this whey protein powder.

According to Transparent Labs, this whey ​product is less processed than most isolates. ​In fact, it has more Immunoglobulins, cysteine, and the prebiotic Lactoferrin, which help boost the immune system.

Transparent Labs ProteinSeries

PROS

  • 100% grass-fed cows are used
  • Contains immune system boosters
  • Lots of protein despite being whey protein concentrate

CONS

  • Whey concentrate isn’t the best version of whey protein


French Vanilla has a classic taste that mixes well with other fluids. They have 5 other flavors available; salted caramel, strawberry, milk chocolate, mocha, and cinnamon pastry.

I personally reach out for either the vanilla or milk chocolate flavor for my morning smoothie.

​Fun tip: Learn how to make homemade waffles using Transparent Labs vanilla protein powder, click here for the recipe.


3 - Legion Whey+ Whey Isolate Protein Powder

Legion Whey prides themselves on having one of the cleanest whey isolate protein powders on the market. This ​whey isolate also claims to be to digested easier than whey concentrate.

​Each serving has 25 grams of protein, and it’s all non-GMO and from 100% grass-fed cows.

This protein powder is more expensive compared to others, but it may be worth it to you based on their quality.

Legion Whey+ Protein

PROS

  • Uses whey isolate protein
  • Non-GMO
  • No hormones, fillers, or unnecessary ingredients

CONS

  • Pricey

The vanilla flavor is very sweet and has a creamy texture after it’s been mixed with a liquid. So if you're not keen on sweets, it's something to consider.

They have 8 other flavors besides vanilla, including mint chocolate, cookies & cream, and strawberry banana.


4 - BSN SYNTHA-6 Whey Protein Powder

Their vanilla flavor is called “vanilla ice cream”, which made me wonder how sweet this protein powder was going to taste. 

Sure enough,  unlike most of the protein powders on this list, it was pretty sweet, just like vanilla ice cream. In addition, it was also hard to mix, so the little balls were definitely reminiscent of ice cream.

BSN SYNTHA-6 Whey Protein Powder

PROS

  • Sweet flavor
  • Lots of protein sources
  • Tastes great even if you only add water

CONS

  • Hard to mix

Each scoop has 22 grams of protein, and the protein source includes whey isolate, whey concentrate, casein ​protein powder, and more. Other flavors include chocolate milkshake, strawberry milkshake, and chocolate peanut butter.

Craving for ice cream? Check out is recipe on Ice cream made from protein powder.


5 - MusclePharm Combat Protein Powder

The vanilla flavor tastes great and can easily be combined with chocolate milk (or any dairy or non-dairy milk), fruits, and vegetables to make a delicious protein shake.

Each serving has 25 grams of protein and comes from 5 different protein sources; whey isolate, whey concentrate, whey protein hydrolysate, egg albumin, and micellar casein. 

Muscle Pharm Combat Protein Powder

PROS

  • 5 different types of protein sources
  • Informed-Choice certified
  • Affordable option

CONS

  • Doesn’t mix well

MusclePharm claims that this blend helps with muscle building, aids in recovery, and ​assist in overall muscle performance, which makes it ideal for athletes.

​With my experience, I had a problem getting the powder to blend with any liquid. I wasn’t a fan of the chunkiness.


6 - Cellucor COR-Performance Protein Powder

This vanilla flavor is called “Whipped Vanilla”. A name like that made me expect the texture would be frothy.

 It turned out  really thick when mixed with water, and I wasn’t a total fan of that.

Otherwise, the taste is better than most unflavored protein powders. They ​also have different flavors like cinnamon swirl and peanut butter marshmallow.

Cellucor COR-Performance Protein Powder

PROS

  • 24 grams of protein
  • Good taste
  • Uses whey isolate

CONS

  • Thick texture

This brand uses whey isolate as their protein source, which means you are getting the most protein-packed whey source. 


7 - Dymatize ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

This brand has two vanilla flavors; gourmet vanilla and natural vanilla. I tried the gourmet vanilla flavor. 

I mixed it with water, and I was surprised by how sweet it was. If you have a sweet tooth, then you’ll like this flavor.

Otherwise, you might get sick of it in a few days.

Dymatize ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

PROS

  • Lots of flavors if you want more than vanilla
  • Uses whey isolate
  • Zero carbohydrates and zero fat

CONS

  • Uses artificial flavors

Each serving has 24 grams of protein. However, it comes with artificial flavoring, which isn’t an ingredient that I like in my protein powders. They have many other flavors available like smooth banana and dutch chocolate.


​8 - Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition uses a whey protein blend in their protein powder. It has whey isolates, whey concentrate, and whey peptides. 

I was impressed that this also contains over 5 grams of BCAAs,  which can help with your fitness routine. So I felt like this would help me ​gain muscle over time.

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey

PROS

  • Uses whey isolates
  • Contains BCAAs
  • Blends easily

CONS

  • Very sweet

I was happy that the vanilla protein powder mixed well with water and didn’t leave behind any small clumps. The vanilla flavor is pretty sweet. I balanced it out by adding ingredients like frozen fruit and lemon juice to make it less sweet and more to my preference. 

Related post: BCAA vs. Whey protein supplement


9 - MuscleTech Phase8 Protein Powder

This is another protein blend powder. It has 7 different protein sources from whey, milk, and eggs.

It seems like overkill, but the company says it allows amino acids to be released for 8 hours after consumption. One scoop has 26 grams of protein. 

The vanilla tasting was great. It was exactly the way it should taste. However, the texture is thick and chalky.

MuscleTech Phase8 Protein Powder 150x150

PROS

  • Takes 8 hours to release amino acids
  • Delicious vanilla flavor
  • 7 different protein sources

CONS

  • Contains artificial flavors

I can see this being a dealbreaker for some people. I wasn’t too impressed with the ingredient list as it contains artificial flavors and lots of ingredients with names that I couldn’t pronounce.


10 - Yuve Vegan Protein Powder

If you’re looking for a vegan vanilla flavor, then you might love this one. 

It uses a plant-based proteins in the ​form of peas and rice. This ensures that you are getting a complete amino acid profile. However, ​it only has 15 grams of protein per serving which is the lowest protein amount out of all of the products I’ve tried.

Yuve Vegan Protein Powder

PROS

  • Vegan-friendly
  • Has ​a complete essential amino acid content
  • Sweet vanilla taste

CONS

  • Most expensive per serving

The vanilla flavor is pretty good, but it was a little too sweet for me. I thought it mixed well, and it tasted delicious when I combined it with other ingredients for a protein shake.

It’s the most expensive per serving on this products list while also having the lowest protein amount, so it may not be the most cost-effective choice. 


​Why Should You Pick Vanilla Over Other Flavors?

You should pick vanilla over other flavors because it’s easier to mix with other ingredients. You can easily combine vanilla protein products with healthy ingredients like yogurt, fruit, honey, and vegetables. It doesn’t mess with tasting as much as other flavors, like chocolate, might.  

​Is Whey or Plant-Based Protein Better for You?

There are a few key differences that may sway you to one side or the other. It can depend on your goals.

  • Plant-based protein doesn’t always have ​a complete amino acid profile. Sometimes a plant protein blend is needed for it to have the complete protein. Whey is always considered a complete protein.
  • Vegetarians or vegans will prefer plant-based protein powder because there are no animal ingredients
  • Pea protein is just as ​​​​​effective as whey protein with building muscle [1]
vegetables

In terms of effectiveness, both whey and plant-based protein products can get you the protein supplement that you need. 

Your health and dietary goals might make plant-based protein more attractive if you are avoiding animal products. However, if your nutrition goals include consuming ​a protein supplement with a complete amino acid profile, then you might want to look at whey protein. [2]

If you want to decide which protein powder is better for you, you might want to dig deeper and evaluate the other ingredients in a protein powder. I would recommend checking for calories, artificial flavors, filler ingredients, and added sugar.

​How Do I Pick the Right Protein Powder for Me?

There are several ​things to consider when choosing a healthy protein powder. You need to consider your physical goals and then pick a protein powder that will help with that. 

Here are some tips on how to pick the right protein powder for you.

  • Looking to build muscle? Whey isolates are a popular choice
  • If you want to lose weight, avoid protein powders with added sugars and BCAAs
  • If you’re vegetarian or vegan, then you may want to avoid whey, casein, and egg protein powders and go for soy, rice, hemp, or pea protein
  • It’s essential to read the ingredient list and check for calories, protein amount, ingredients, and more to check that it meets your standard

​Check out this video for more helpful tips ...

FAQs

Best tasting vanilla protein powder FAQ Banner

When is the best time to take protein powder? 

What can I add to a vanilla protein shake?

How much protein do I need a day? 

Is protein powder good for weight loss? 

Is protein powder good for muscle gain? 

​the Best-Tasting Vanilla Protein Shake Is ...

Vanilla protein powders are a great base to make delicious protein shakes. Luckily, there are a lot of available options that taste great. There is one that stood out to me though. I enjoyed the Ora Organic Vegan Protein Powder benefits the most, and I think it's one of the best tasting protein vanilla powders

I enjoyed the plant-based protein sources, and the organic superfood made me feel like I was getting so ​much vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients in ​a single drink. 

If you want to try it, then head over here to try their vanilla ​variant. It tastes good, although the chocolate flavor and vanilla chai gets rave reviews from other people too.

Have you tried any of these vanilla protein powders? What did you like?

​Ora Organic
Our #1 ​Vanilla Protein Powder

  • Vegan-friendly
  • USDA Organic
  • Complete protein
  • 2 Servings of Greens
  • BEST PRICE until the end of March

​For more ideas on how to make your protein powder taste good, click here.

About the author

Connor Sellers

Connor Sellers is a personal trainer and senior coach at Total Shape. His mission is to inspire people to relentlessly pursue their fitness and lifestyle goals. He believes staying fit has an overall positive effect on one’s body, mind, and spirit. Read more about him here​.

>