17
Considered
119
of Research
95
Examined
9
Interviewed
Vanilla is one of the most popular flavors for everything for a good reason. It has a rich smell and taste.
It’s no surprise that for many protein powders, vanilla tastes a little different. Some of them can’t seem to get the flavor right. It’s either too sweet or too bland.
I took the time to try out some best vanilla powders to find the best one.
Here is what I discovered about the best vanilla-flavored protein in the market.
The Best-Tasting Vanilla Protein Powders
- Best Tasting Overall Vanilla Protein Powder: Transparent Labs
- Cheapest Tasting Vanilla Protein Powder: Ora Organic Vegan
- Best Tasty Vegan-Friendly Protein Powder: Live Conscious
- Best Tasting CFS Certified Vanilla Protein Powder: Ladder
- Best Tasting Non-GMO Vanilla Protein Powder: Legion Whey+
- Best Dessert-Like Vanilla Protein Powder: BSN SYNTHA-6
- Most Delicious Vanilla Protein Powder for Athletes: MusclePharm
- Best Tasting High-Protein Vanilla Powder: Cellucor COR-Performance Powder
- Best Tasting Vanilla Protein Powder with Flavor Variety: Dymatize ISO100
Best Tasting Vanilla Protein Powders (December 2023)
1 - Transparent Labs Grass Fed Whey Protein Isolate (Best Overall)
This grass-fed whey protein isolate means that the whey protein content is higher than its concentrate counterpart, with 24 grams of protein for every scoop.
According to Transparent Labs, this best-tasting protein powder is less processed than most isolates. In fact, it has more immunoglobulins, cysteine, and the prebiotic lactoferrin, which help boost the immune system.
French Vanilla has a classic taste that mixes well with other fluids. This whey protein isolate has 5 other flavors available; salted caramel, strawberry, milk chocolate, mocha, and cinnamon pastry.
- Calories: 120
- Protein: 28g
- Carbs: 2g
- Fat: 0g
- 100% grass-fed cows are used for whey isolate
- Contains immune system boosters
- Lots of protein despite being whey protein concentrate
- whey protein concentrate isn’t the best version of whey source
In my fitness journey, I’ve tried various protein powders, but the Transparent Labs always hits the spot. Every morning, the ritual of blending the vanilla flavor into my smoothie not only elevates the taste but gives me the protein kick I need to start my day. It’s not just about the flavor; it’s the smooth texture and how easily it mixes that makes it a staple in my daily routine.
Get 10% off using coupon code: TOTALSHAPE
2 - Live Conscious Protein (Best Vegan-Friendly)
This vegan-friendly product derives its protein from plant-based sources like yellow pea protein, brown rice, sacha inchi seed, and pumpkin seed.
Live Conscious’ organic powder claims that it can speed up metabolism and support muscle growth.
It is true that with 15g per scoop, you get less protein compared to other products but it can help increase your daily protein.
I remember the skepticism I had when I first decided to try Live Conscious Protein. Being a fitness enthusiast, I’ve always been picky about my protein sources. But this one? It was a pleasant surprise.
The sweetness is just right, not overpowering, making my post-workout refueling enjoyable. It’s not just a protein supplement; it’s a treat I look forward to after every workout.
It's surprisingly good, especially since a lot of other plant-based protein powder supplements have bland flavors.
Supplement Facts
- Calories: 80
- Protein: 15g
- Carbs: 3g
- Fat: 0.5g
- Free of soy, gluten, and sugar
- Vegan-friendly
- Manufactured in the USA and third-party tested for label accuracy
- Lower protein amount per serving
3 - Ladder Whey Protein (CFS Certified)
Ladder used vanilla beans to create that natural vanilla flavor, mixing in some salt and a little hint of natural sweetener to bolden up the taste.
The result is a healthy protein drink that tastes like your favorite vanilla ice cream. The best part is the natural taste, making it enjoyable to consume regardless of where you are. You need not worry about it tasting like cough medicine, unlike some other brands.
We also did a full review on this Ladder whey powder.
- Calories: 130
- Protein: 26g
- Carbs: 5g
- Fat: 0.5g
- CFS Certified
- All-natural ingredients
- Excellent taste without artificial sweeteners
- Complete of essential and branched-chain amino acids
- A little bit on the pricier side
It’s like drinking your favorite dessert shake and getting the essential nutrients your body needs.
4 - Ora Organic Vegan Protein Powder (Cheapest Option)
Ora has a unique vegan protein powder available with not one, not two, but THREE protein sources: organic brown rice, pea, and hemp.
On top of that, it has over 20 high-quality organic superfoods to help support your cognitive function and muscle protein synthesis.
Their vanilla flavor gets lots of rave reviews for having a clean taste. I only mix it with water, and it tastes great.
- Calories: 120
- Protein: 21g
- Carbs: 4g
- Fat: 2.5g
- Source of organic brown rice protein, pea, and hemp
- Vegan-friendly
- USDA Organic
- A little gritty texture if you don’t shake well
You can’t go wrong with their other two flavors though; chocolate and Vanilla Chai are delicious in their own right.
This one is considered one of the best protein powder products in the vegan community.
"I have been searching to find a plant-based protein powder that was tasty and not chalky. This powder passed the test."
- Gayla W, Ora User
5 - Legion Whey+ (Non-GMO)
Legion Whey+ prides itself on having one of the market's cleanest grass-fed whey protein isolate powders. This whey isolate also claims to be digested easier than its concentrate version.
Each serving has 22 grams of protein, and it's all non-GMO and from 100% grass-fed cows.
This whey protein powder is more expensive than others, but it may be worth it to you based on its quality.
- Calories: 100
- Protein: 22g
- Carbs: 2g
- Fat: 0g
- Uses grass-fed whey protein isolate
- Non-GMO
- No hormones, fillers, or unnecessary ingredients
- Pricey
Being a bit of a ‘protein powder connoisseur’, I didn’t expect to be blown away. But Legion Whey+ did just that. The creamy texture and the rich vanilla flavor make each drink a delightful experience.
It’s not just about the protein content for me anymore; it’s about enjoying each sip, knowing I’m fueling my body with something that tastes this good.
So if you're not keen on sweets, it's something to consider.
This whey protein isolate has 8 other flavors besides vanilla, including mint chocolate, cookies & cream, and strawberry banana.
6 - BSN SYNTHA-6 Whey Protein Powder (Best Dessert-Like)
Their vanilla flavor is called “vanilla ice cream,” which made me wonder how sweet this powder would taste.
Sure enough, unlike most of the best-tasting whey protein powder products on this list, it was pretty sweet, just like vanilla ice cream.
In addition, it was also hard to mix, so the little balls were reminiscent of ice cream.
- Calories: 200
- Protein: 22g
- Carbs: 14g
- Fat: 6g
- Sweet flavor
- Lots of whey protein sources
- Tastes great even if you only add water
- Hard to mix
Each whey protein scoop has 22 grams of protein, and the protein source includes whey isolate, whey concentrate, casein protein powder, and more. Other flavors include chocolate milkshake, strawberry milkshake, and chocolate peanut butter.
7 - MusclePharm Combat Protein Powder (Best for Athletes)
The vanilla flavor tastes great and can easily be combined with chocolate milk (or any dairy or non-dairy milk), fruits, and vegetables to make a delicious protein drink.
Each serving has 25 grams of protein and comes from 5 different protein sources: whey protein isolate and concentrate, whey protein hydrolysate, egg albumin, and micellar casein protein.
MusclePharm claims that this blend helps with muscle protein synthesis, aids in recovery, and assists in overall muscle performance, which makes it ideal protein powder for runners and other athletes.
- Calories: 130
- Protein: 25g
- Carbs: 4g
- Fat: 1.5g
- 5 different types of protein sources
- Informed-Choice certified
- Affordable option
- Doesn’t mix well
I’ve always been on the lookout for a protein powder that blends seamlessly. MusclePharm, with its rich flavor, was a contender, but the blending was a bit of a hurdle.
Yet, the taste made up for it, turning my protein shakes into something I look forward to, chunkiness and all.
8 - Cellucor COR-Performance Powder (Best High-Protein)
This vanilla flavor is called “Whipped Vanilla”. A name like that made me expect the texture would be frothy.
It turned out really thick when mixed with water, and I wasn’t a total fan of that.
Otherwise, the taste is better than most unflavored protein powders. They also have different flavors like cinnamon swirl and peanut butter marshmallow.
- Calories: 120
- Protein: 24g
- Carbs: 4g
- Fat: 1.5g
- 24 grams of protein
- Good taste
- Uses whey protein isolate
- Thick texture
This brand uses whey isolate as their protein source, which means you are getting the most protein-packed whey source.
9 - Dymatize ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder (Best with Flavor Variety)
This brand has two vanilla flavors; gourmet vanilla and natural vanilla. I tried the gourmet vanilla flavor.
My first encounter with Dymatize was marked by an unexpected sweetness, a pleasant surprise that made each sip a delightful experience.
As a fitness enthusiast, every gram of protein counts, but who says it can’t be a delightful experience? Dymatize makes each serving not just a step towards my fitness goals, but a sweet journey to be savored.
If you have a sweet tooth, then you’ll like this flavor.
Otherwise, you might get sick of it in a few days.
- Calories: 110
- Protein: 25g
- Carbs: 1g
- Fat: 0g
- Lots of flavors if you want more than vanilla
- Uses whey isolate
- Zero carbohydrates and zero fat
- Uses artificial flavors
Each protein vanilla serving has 25 grams of protein. However, it comes with artificial flavoring, which isn’t an ingredient that I want in the best-tasting powders. They have many other flavors available like smooth banana and dutch chocolate protein powder.
10 - Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey
Optimum Nutrition contains a protein blend of whey isolates, concentrate, and peptides.
I was impressed that this also contains over 5 grams of BCAAs, important amino acids that can help your fitness routine. So I felt like this would help me gain muscle over time.
- Calories: 120
- Protein: 24g
- Carbs: 4g
- Fat: 1g
- Uses whey protein isolates
- Contains branched chain amino acids and other important amino acids
- Protein vanilla blends easily
- Very sweet
I was happy that the whey protein powder mixed well with water and didn’t leave behind any small clumps. However, the vanilla flavor is pretty sweet. I balanced it out by adding ingredients like frozen fruit and lemon juice to make it less sweet and more to my preference.
Related post: BCAA vs. Whey Protein Supplement
11 - MuscleTech Phase8 Protein
This is another protein blend powder. It has seven different protein sources: whey, milk, and eggs.
It seems overkill, but the company says it allows essential amino acids (AAs) to be released for 8 hours after consumption. One scoop has 26 grams of protein.
The vanilla tasting was great. It was precisely the way it should taste. However, the texture is thick and chalky.
- Calories: 150
- Protein: 26g
- Carbs: 8g
- Fat: 1.5g
- Takes 8 hours to release essential amino acids
- Delicious protein vanilla flavor
- 7 different protein sources
- Contains artificial flavors
As someone who values both taste and nutritional content, MuscleTech struck a balance. Yes, the texture is something to get used to, but every sip is a reminder of the powerhouse of essential amino acids fueling my body. It’s a compromise I’m willing to make for the sake of my fitness journey.
I wasn’t too impressed with the ingredient list as it contains artificial flavors and lots of ingredients with names that I couldn’t pronounce.
12 - Yuve Vegan Protein Powder
If you’re looking for a vegan vanilla flavor, then you might love this one.
It uses a plant-based proteins in the form of rice and pea protein. This ensures that you are getting the nine essential amino acids for optimum nutrition.
However, it only has 15 grams of pea protein per serving which is the lowest protein amount out of all of the products I’ve tried.
The protein vanilla flavor is pretty good, but it was a little too sweet for me. I thought it mixed well, and it tasted delicious when I combined it with other ingredients for a protein drink.
- Calories: 110
- Protein: 15g
- Carbs: 12g
- Fat: 2.5g
- Vegan-friendly
- Has a complete essential amino acid content from pea protein and brown rice protein
- Sweet protein vanilla taste
- Most expensive per serving
It’s the most expensive per serving on this products list while also having the lowest protein amount, so it may not be the most cost-effective choice for protein vanilla.
How We Tested the Best Tasting Vanilla Protein Powders
Each product was evaluated based on its ingredient quality, brand reputation, and customer reviews.
We established a set of criteria to ensure a comprehensive and unbiased review:
- Taste: The primary focus was on the flavor. We looked for a smooth, rich vanilla taste that wasn’t too overpowering or artificial.
- Mixability: How well does the powder blend with liquids? We tested this with both water and milk to evaluate consistency and texture.
- Nutritional Value: We analyzed the protein content, added sugars, and other nutritional elements to ensure the powders contribute to a balanced diet.
- Value for Money: Assessing whether the quality and quantity justify the price.
Our diverse team of testers included professional athletes, fitness enthusiasts, and individuals new to the protein supplement world to ensure varied taste preferences and dietary needs were considered.
Each protein powder underwent a rigorous testing process:
- Taste Test: Each tester sampled the protein powders in a blind taste test to eliminate brand bias. They rated the flavor, aftertaste, and overall taste experience.
- Mixing Test: We evaluated how easily the powders mixed into liquids, checking for clumps or residue.
- Physical Performance Assessment: Testers incorporated the protein powders into their diet and monitored any noticeable changes in their energy levels, muscle recovery, and overall physical performance.
- Nutritional Analysis: We collaborated with nutrition experts to delve deeper into the nutritional labels, assessing the quality and health benefits of the ingredients.
- Feedback Collection: Every tester provided detailed feedback on their experience, which we meticulously analyzed to arrive at our final conclusions.
What We Look For in A Vanilla Protein Powder
When it comes to selecting the best-tasting vanilla protein powder, we take several key factors into consideration.
Our comprehensive evaluation process ensures that the products featured in this buyer's guide meet our strict criteria for quality and flavor.
Here are the essential elements we focus on:
Taste
Taste is paramount when it comes to a vanilla protein powder. After all, no one wants to consume a supplement that leaves a bland or artificial aftertaste.
We thoroughly assess the taste profile of each product, looking for those that deliver a rich, smooth, and well-balanced vanilla flavor.
Our goal is to recommend protein powders that not only provide the nutritional benefits but also make every shake or smoothie a delightful treat.
Protein Content
The protein content of a powder is a crucial aspect of any protein supplement.
We analyze the protein per serving in each product, considering both the quantity and quality of the protein source.
Our focus is on powders that offer a substantial amount of protein per serving, ensuring they provide an effective boost to muscle recovery and growth.
Whether it's whey-based or plant-based protein, we look for products with complete amino acid profiles to support overall health and fitness goals.
Value
We understand the importance of providing our readers with products that offer value for their investment.
As such, we assess the overall value proposition of each vanilla protein powder, considering factors such as price, serving size, and the number of servings per container.
We aim to recommend products that strike a balance between affordability and quality, making them accessible to a wide range of buyers.
Online Rating
The feedback from consumers plays a crucial role in our evaluation process.
We take into account the online ratings and reviews from verified buyers to gauge the real-world experiences with the products.
By considering the collective sentiment, we gain valuable insights into the product's consistency, performance, and overall customer satisfaction.
Products with consistently positive online ratings are more likely to earn a spot on our top recommendations list.
Who Should Buy a Vanilla Protein Powder?
Anyone looking to supplement their diet with a convenient and delicious protein source, particularly those who enjoy the flavor of vanilla, should buy a vanilla protein powder. It is especially beneficial for individuals engaged in fitness or muscle-building activities.
Who Shouldn't Buy a Vanilla Protein Powder?
Individuals who have allergies or sensitivities to ingredients commonly found in vanilla-flavored products or those who dislike the taste of vanilla shouldn't buy a vanilla protein powder. Additionally, those who already consume sufficient protein through their regular diet and do not require additional supplementation may not need to buy a vanilla protein powder.
Why Should You Pick Vanilla Over Other Flavors?
You should pick protein vanilla over other flavors because it’s easier to mix with other ingredients. You can easily combine vanilla flavored products with healthy ingredients like yogurt, fruit, honey, and vegetables. It doesn’t mess with tasting as much as other flavors, like chocolate flavor might.
Is Whey or Plant-Based Protein Better for You?
To determine whether it's whey protein or plant-based protein that is better for you, you must first identify your goals.
- Plant-based protein doesn’t always have a complete amino acid profile [1]. Sometimes a plant protein blend is needed for it to have the complete protein. Whey is always considered a complete protein [2].
- Vegetarians or vegans will prefer plant-based protein powder because there are no animal ingredients.
- Pea protein is just as effective as whey protein in building muscle [3].
In terms of effectiveness, both whey protein and plant-based protein products can get you the protein supplement that you need.
Your health and dietary goals might make plant-based protein more attractive if you are avoiding animal products.
However, if your nutrition goals include consuming a protein vanilla supplement with a complete amino acid profile, then you might want to look at whey-based proteins [4].
If you want to decide which protein powder is better for you, you might want to dig deeper and evaluate the ingredients in your choices. I would recommend checking for calories, artificial flavors, filler ingredients, essential amino acids, and added sugar [5].
Here is an in-depth guide to Plant Protein vs. Whey: Here’s What You Need to Know
Nutritional Benefits and Diet Compatibility
Vanilla protein powders offer diverse nutritional benefits, making them suitable for various diet plans.
For keto enthusiasts, low-carb vanilla protein options provide essential amino acids while minimizing carbohydrates.
Vegans can benefit from plant-based vanilla proteins, often derived from peas, rice, or hemp, offering a complete amino acid profile while being dairy-free.
Those following a gluten-free diet can opt for certified gluten-free vanilla protein powders, ensuring safe consumption.
Vanilla protein powders are versatile and can be incorporated into shakes, smoothies, or baked goods, accommodating a range of dietary preferences while supporting muscle growth, satiety, and overall nutrition in different ways.
FAQs
When Is the Best Time to Take Protein Powder?
The best time to take protein powder is debated greatly with studies conflicting with each other. One study suggests taking it within two hours of working out, and another study says it doesn’t matter what time as long as you take enough protein vanilla.
What Can I Add to a Vanilla-Flavored Protein Shake?
You can add pretty much anything to a vanilla-flavored whey protein shake. The list of potential ingredients includes fruit, sugar, sweeteners, yogurt, cinnamon, chocolate peanut butter, vanilla ice cream, and whatever else you think would taste good with vanilla.
How Much Protein Do I Need a Day?
How much protein you need a day will depend on many factors like age, gender, diet, and activity level. For example, an average male who is at a healthy weight and doesn’t lift weights or exercise much should aim for 56-91 grams of protein a day, and an average woman who meets the same criteria will need 46-75 grams per day.
Is Protein Powder Good for Weight Loss?
Yes, protein powder is good for weight loss. One study shows that protein helps with keeping you full longer, and in theory, this means you will eat less and therefore consume fewer calories which helps your diet.
Is Protein Powder Good for Muscle Gain?
Yes, protein powder is good for muscle gain. It contains essential amino acids that your body needs to aid muscle development and increase muscle strength, and if your protein intake from the food you eat is insufficient, you should consider taking one to help with muscle protein synthesis.
The Best Tasting Vanilla Protein Powder Is ...
Vanilla-flavored protein powders are a great base to make delicious protein shakes. Luckily, there are a lot of available options that taste great.
There is one that stood out to me though.
I enjoyed the Transparent Labs the most, I think it's one of the best tasting protein powders out of all those I tried.
Because it’s whey isolate, I get more out of its protein content.
I also appreciate that it’s from grass-fed sources. I gravitate towards grass-fed protein sources for my whey supplements, I think it makes the content cleaner and more natural.
And there’s no chalky and weird taste or texture, so I can take it with just water or flavor it with some berries.
Have you tried any of these best tasting protein powders? What did you like?
Our #1 Vanilla Protein Powder
Transparent Labs Grass Fed Whey Protein Isolate (Best Overall)
- 100% grass-fed cows are used for whey isolate
- Contains immune system boosters
- Lots of protein despite being whey protein concentrate
- Get 10% off using code: TOTALSHAPE
- whey protein concentrate isn’t the best version of whey source
About The Author
You May Also Like
I don’t usually like protein powders, but this one is the best tasting I’ve ever had. It’s not too sweet and it has a vanilla flavor that doesn’t make you feel like you’re eating chalk. I would recommend this to anyone who is looking for the best tasting vanilla protein powder.
Cellucor COR Performance is the best tasting vanilla protein powder on the market. It tastes so good that it actually makes me want to drink my protein shake every day. I have tried dozens of flavors in my life, but this one is really by far the best!
I don’t like protein powder. It’s generally gross and all the flavors taste the same to me. I decided to give Dymatize ISO100 a try because I heard they have the best tasting vanilla protein powder in the market. The reviews are true! This is by far my favorite vanilla flavor, better than any other brand that I’ve tried in the past.
Optimum Nutrition is the best tasting protein powder I’ve ever had. It’s worth every penny because I actually enjoy drinking it! The vanilla flavor is nice and light, without any overwhelming aftertaste. And it mixes well in water, milk, or anything else I want to put it in. Definitely recommend!
I’ve tried a lot of protein powders over the years but this is one of the best tasting. I tried it at a friend’s house after a workout and loved it. The vanilla flavor is spot on and tastes great mixed in with almond milk or water. I usually don’t like protein powders that come in tubs but this one has been my favorite so far
I’m a big fan of Yuve Vegan. I like how it is made with all natural ingredients and doesn’t contain any animal byproducts. Obviously, the taste is what got me hooked! It’s the best tasting vanilla protein powder I know of, and it’s also easily digestible, which can be hard to find in natural products.
Transparent Labs is the best tasting Vanilla protein powder that I have tried. It has a smooth and creamy texture while still being light and fluffy. I love the natural sweetener that is used in it- it’s not too sweet but just enough to add enough flavor without any added sugar. I also really like the simple ingredients list.
Transparent Labs is the best tasting vanilla protein powder, hands down. If you’re looking for a protein powder that will make you want to drink it, this is the one! It has a sweet taste and mixes well with any of my favorite workout drinks. I feel like I can focus better while training on this product and it has been a great addition to my routine.
As someone who used to drink protein powder all day, I can honestly say that Legion Whey+ is the best tasting protein powder I have come across. The taste of vanilla is smooth and reminds me of a cake batter dip. My favorite aspect of this protein powder is that it manages to not be too sweet or too salty. It’s just perfect!
Personally, I believe that BPN vanilla protein powder is the most delicious protein powder because it lacks the protein aftertaste. It only contains a small portion of it. My family is also not a big fan of the protein powder craze. They did, however, enjoy the vanilla BPN protein powder. Personally, I believe it is the best tasting.
I love BSN SYNTHA-6, but I’m not surprised to hear that it’s best tasting vanilla protein powder. It’s a great way to start my day and I really love the flavor! I also use it as a post-workout snack and it never fails to help me recover quickly.