Total Shape is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Is Maple Syrup Vegan? (5 Problematic Ingredients)

Isaac Robertson
Published by Isaac Robertson
Fact checked by Donald Christman, BHSc FACT CHECKED
Last updated: February 26, 2023

Maple syrup has proven to be a fantastic substitute for table sugar that many vegans rely on, but some maple syrups can hide unexpected animal ingredients.

So, what should you watch out for when selecting a bottle of this sticky, unique-tasting sweetener? Do vegans eat maple syrup?

Our team will fill you in on everything you need to know about possible non-vegan ingredients in maple syrup, so keep on reading to find out how it’s made, how to tell if your maple syrup is vegan, and what vegan maple syrups you should try.

Quick Summary

  • Maple syrup that is vegan is normally labeled 100% pure maple syrup or organic.
  • The best Maple syrup for vegan brands includes eggo syrup, Aunt Jemima, wholesome Maple syrup, Hungry jack, and log cabin maple syrup.
  • Some ingredients in maple syrup raise questions for vegans include sugar, honey, food coloring, animal fat, and butter flavor.
  • Pure Maple syrup is healthier when compared to table sugar, or other sweeteners.

How Is Maple Syrup Made?

Maple syrup being poured in a flat surface

The process of making maple syrup involves several steps: preparation for maple sap-collecting season, done in early springtime.

After the holes are created in the trunks of maple trees, the precious sap leaks out and gets trapped in special containers.

Up until this point, it appears that based on how it’s made, organic maple syrup from maple trees is entirely vegan-friendly.

However, this is where things can get a bit messy. The next step is boiling the maple sap, which allows the syrup to become more concentrated and dense.

Still, sometimes this stage of the production process may involve some animal ingredients that can end up in your organic maple syrup container.

After the boiling process, ‘’The syrup is graded based on its color and strength, with Canada having a slightly different system to the United States, and even that in the US differing slightly between states.’’ [1]

Most common varieties include:

  • Red Maple (Acer rubrum)
  • Sugar Maple (Acer saccharum)
  • Black Maple (Acer negrum)

What Is Pure Maple Syrup?

Pure maple syrup is 100% pure, unlike imitation maple syrups that come with some suspicious ingredients like chemical food dyes, stabilizers, artificial maple extract, or honey.

Luckily, there are several excellent maple syrup brands which check all the boxes of your plant-based pantry.

So, what makes pure maple syrup vegan is the absence of any artificial or animal-derived ingredients.

Okay, real maple syrup may cost you a bit more than you expected, but if you’re serious about your vegan lifestyle, it might be worth the extra cash.

5 Problematic Ingredients

Close up shot of a maple syrup being poured out of a bottle

These are the usual suspects that make organic maple syrup non-vegan:

1. Sugar

The production process of white sugar often involves animal ingredients, namely, animal bone char, which is a deal-breaker for many vegans.

2. Food colorings and flavors

These ingredients are commonly found in all sorts of processed foods, and some maple syrups are no exception. Some of these flavorings and colors may be animal-derived, like castoreum or red food dye that often comes from insects.

3. Honey

Another ingredient that most vegans frown upon since it’s extracted from bees.

4. Butter Flavor

Some Pancake Syrups and Maple Syrups don’t qualify as vegan since they contain this milk-derived ingredient. However, some maple syrups that include “butter” in their name are vegan-friendly; and you can find the exact brands in the vegan maple syrup list below.

5. Animal fat

Finally, there have been reports that some maple syrup manufacturers use animal products, such as animal fat, in the process of defoaming the maple tree sap. Still, we were not able to confirm this.

However, keep your eyes open for allergy warnings on your maple syrup bottle such as ‘may contain traces of milk’ or similar as this might be a sign that some dairy-based defoaming substance may have been used on the pancake syrup.

How to Choose a Vegan Maple Syrup?

If you’ve been racking your brains trying to figure out ‘’is maple syrup vegan?’’ and "do vegans eat maple syrup?", just pay attention to two things. As long as the label says it’s 100% pure maple syrup - it’s the real deal, meaning that maple syrup is vegan. If the label from the specific maple syrup company product also reads ‘’organic’’, you can be sure it’s vegan-friendly.

According to the Vermont Organic Farmers,

‘’Any organic product can only use certified organic vegetable oils in production.’’

- Northeast Organic Farming Association of Vermont, [2]

A short ingredients list is another factor that makes maple syrup vegan. Kosher brands are usually safe bets, too.

10 Vegan Brands

Vegan maple syrup brands

If you can’t be bothered by checking the ingredients list to make sure your maple syrup is vegan, next time you want to restock on your plant-based sweetener, just pick some of these vegan-certified brands:

  1. Log Cabin Maple Syrup (Original, Sugar-Free, All-Natural, Light)
  2. Mrs. Buttersworth (Original, Sugar-Free, Light)
  3. Aunt Jemima (Original, Sugar-Free, Light, Butter-Lite, Country Rich)
  4. Hungry Jack (Original, Sugar-Free, Light, Butter, Cinnamon Brown-Sugar)
  5. Great Value (Walmart) Pure Maple Syrup
  6. Abbie’s Pancake Syrup (Classic)
  7. Maple Grove Farms Syrup (All Maple Syrups and Pancake Syrups)
  8. Eggo Syrup (Original)
  9. Kirkland Maple Syrup (Original)
  10. Wholesome Maple Syrup (All Varieties)

Whether you’re after a thicker, more robust syrup or a lighter version, high-end or more budget-friendly products, a variety of vegan-friendly maple syrup products will have you covered.

Is It Healthy?

Although it’s about three times sweeter than table sugar, this breakfast staple is actually a healthier option compared to other sweeteners, especially if it’s pure maple syrup.

‘’The glycemic index of maple syrup is around 54. In comparison, table sugar has a glycemic index of around 65. This implies that maple syrup raises blood sugar slower than regular sugar.’’

- Kris Gunnars, BSc, [3]

Maple syrup is also a bit more nutritious than granulated sugar as it contains small amounts of minerals, such as zinc, potassium, and magnesium. It also comes with a couple of antioxidants.

Although these are good reasons to add maple syrup to your diet, try not to go overboard with it.

Despite being a healthier substitute to other sweeteners, it’s still loaded with sugar, which is not something you should consume in high doses if you want to avoid diabetes, obesity, and a number of other health issues.

Should You Add Maple Syrup to Your Diet?

Most maple syrups are vegan and are a great addition to a plant-based lifestyle.

Plus, if you are conscious about the environmental impacts of products you consume on a daily basis, you’ll love the fact that maple syrup is also eco-friendly, which cannot be said for other common sweeteners.

As a bonus, maple syrup is actually one of the healthier sweeteners out there, so don’t hesitate to top your favorite vegan ice cream or smother a batch of pancakes with this sublime-tasting plant-based sweetener.

How do you use maple syrup, and what brands would be your top picks? Let us know in the comments below.


Was this article helpful?

About The Author

You May Also Like

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *