Total Shape is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Is It Safe To Mix Protein Powders? (From a Nutritionist)

Isaac Robertson
Published by Isaac Robertson
Fact checked by Donald Christman, BHSc FACT CHECKED
Last updated: January 18, 2022

This is a question quite a few of my clients ask me, and in most cases, I tell them to stick with the protein formula they buy. But there are times when you might want to mix protein powders to achieve better results.

But before you simply order a few random protein shakes and come up with your own blend, let me show you what I learned from my nutritionist.

As a personal trainer, this is important information that I share with my clients to help them succeed.

There are a few simple mistakes people seem to make, and I even had a misconception about some plant-based proteins.

Let's get right into it.

Quick Summary

  • Some products don't have the right protein content to support muscle growth unless you mix them.
  • Mixing protein powders should always aim to create a better amino acid profile. 
  • Whey and casein protein are two options that people often mix, but it's the one combination that might not be ideal.

Is It Safe To Mix Protein Powders?

white powder in a bowl and spoon

Yes, it's generally safe to mix protein powders, and you shouldn't find that it causes any major issue for your body or digestive system.

See, when it comes to mixing proteins, all you're doing is combining things that you'd regularly combine in your meal plans.

Here's what I mean.

If you had a breakfast of oatmeal with milk and scrambled eggs and a few chicken strips, then you'd be combining multiple different protein sources.

The same would be the case if you had a glass of soy milk to wash down a lunch of rice with beans and peas.

The only thing I would suggest is to be careful not to take a huge amount of protein powder by adding a full scoop from multiple different tubs. Unless your stomach is used to a large protein supply, you might feel bloated.

2 Advantages of Mixing Protein Powders

smiling woman with a drink

There are two main advantages that I find you get from mixing two or more protein powders.

Adding Flavor

First of all, if you have found a great quality powder, but you simply aren't a fan of the flavor, then you can mix it with a different one.

One of my clients does this with an unflavored Optimum Nutrition product that he mixes with a Transparent Labs chocolate protein powder.

Different Amino Acid Needs

The more important reason for doing this is that the average adult has a specific need for certain amino acids [1]. But an athlete will require some proteins more than others.

And when you look at the majority of plant-based proteins, you actually need to mix different ones to get the full amino acid profile from your protein intake.

2 Disadvantages Of Mixing Protein Powders

man holding up a drink with a disgusted face

There are also two occurrences that usually make people stay clear of mixing protein powders and miss all the benefits of the process.

Blending Inconsistency

The biggest disadvantage I have encountered with protein powders is that some of them mix easier than others. Some protein powders will quickly dissolve in water, while others require a blender. And when you mix them into one protein shake, you can end up with a weird consistency.

Difficulty Setting the Protein Profile Right

The other thing I would highlight is that when you try to create your own mix of different types, you might not end up with the ideal daily protein intake to support growing lean muscle mass.

Unless you get the amino acid profile just right, you could end up further away from your fitness goals. And with some types of protein being slow-digesting, you could end up with less than optimal recovery times.

What Types Of Protein Should You Mix?

The first thing I would say is that you can just ignore mixing whey protein and casein protein. Both provide the maximum amino acid profile, and there really isn't a huge benefit of doing this.

And for those that are lactose intolerant or vegan, whey and casein protein intake isn't an option.

What I would suggest in this case is to combine pea, rice, and soy protein powder into one shake. With the same protein intake volume of, say, 25 grams [2], you'll get a much better amino acid exposure to maximize recovery times.

"According to this research, which focused on how much protein athletes need and when they need it, you should consume 0.54-0.91g per pound of bodyweight daily." - Runnersworld.com.

FAQs

What Should You Not MIX With Protein Powder?

One thing you should avoid mixing with protein powder is any form of artificial flavor or sweetener. The reason is that many chemical sweeteners may impact your gut health, and that will make digesting protein shakes more difficult.

What Is the Best Way to MIX Protein Powders?

The best way to mix different protein powders is to add them to water in a shaker. Depending on your personal preference, that should give the protein shakes a smoother consistency and make them more enjoyable to drink.

Have You Tried Mixing Up Your Protein Intake?

As with other supplements, it's always important to get the right dose of macronutrients like protein.

And while most protein powders are formulated to give you a good combination of amino acids, it is possible to achieve better balances, especially with plant protein.

Generally speaking, you won't have any major issues from doing this. But I would say that you might want to get advice from a nutritionist on getting the ideal mix for protein and other nutrients.


References:

  1. https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpendo.00466.2001
  2. https://www.runnersworld.com/uk/nutrition/diet/a775294/how-to-plan-your-protein-for-optimal-muscle-recovery/

About The Author

You May Also Like

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *