Protein Bars vs Shakes (2024 Updated) Which One is better?

James Cunningham, BSc, CPT
Published by James Cunningham, BSc, CPT | Staff Writer & Senior Coach
Last updated: June 19, 2024
Our content is meticulously researched and reviewed by an expert team of fact checkers and medical professionals. They ensure accuracy, relevance, and timeliness using the latest reputable sources, which are cited within the text and listed at the end of the article. Before publication and upon significant updates, we confirm factual accuracy, committed to providing readers with well-informed content. Learn more.

As an experienced Health and Performance Coach with a diverse clientele, I frequently encounter a common debate among fitness enthusiasts: the superiority of protein bars versus protein shakes.

This topic, often a subject of lively discussions, has prompted me to delve deeper into the nuances of both options.

In this article, I aim to shed light on this debate, drawing from my extensive experience and knowledge in the field, to guide you toward making an informed choice that aligns with your health and fitness goals.

Quick Summary

  • Protein shakes are a superior choice for serious muscle building, while bars are great for on-the-go nutrition and for weight loss.
  • Protein bars should be taken in between meals for weight loss. If you want to gain muscles and recover from your fitness routine, take protein shakes within two hours of working out.
  • ​A protein shake can have 20-30 grams of protein per serving. Compared to protein bars which are usually 10-15 grams of protein per serving.
  • In my professional view, the choice between protein bars and shakes ultimately hinges on individual lifestyle and fitness goals.

Which Is a Better Source for Protein?

proteing powder

Quality whey protein powder is a better source for people who are looking to form and build muscles as it provides a high concentration of amino acids that aid in muscle growth and recovery post-workout.

From personal experience, I've found it particularly effective for enhancing muscle formation. It's also adaptable for various diets like vegan, keto, or gluten-free, with many powders tailored to these specific needs.

On the other hand, protein bars can be a better fit for those focusing on fat loss, especially if you're on a calorie-restricted diet.

They're convenient for ensuring you receive essential nutrients and protein while keeping your calorie intake in check. However, it's important to remember that excess protein can convert to fat, potentially leading to weight gain.

Which Has Better Nutrition?

chocolate bar

From my observations with various clients, I've found that protein bars often offer better overall nutrition compared to shakes.

For example, some of my clients who prefer on-the-go snacks have benefited from the diverse nutritional profile of protein bars, especially those who need quick energy boosts without the hassle of preparation.

Let’s break down how a protein bar​ and protein powder ​differ in nutritional value.

Protein Bars

If you need a quick and easy snack, a protein bar ​is readily available anytime with no elaborate prep. Plus, most bars have a variety of flavors available, so you can have a different one for every snack. Check out some of the best meal replacement bars here.

I’ve noticed that food products like protein bars usually ​come high in carbohydrates, which ​​can be ​used by the body for recovery and repair after a fitness workout. It also can have other healthy nutrients like vitamins B6, C, E, and B12.

The biggest issue I’ve seen with protein bars is it can have a lot of added sugar and calories.

Some of them can even have the same or more amount of sugar as candy bars. There isn’t as much sugar or calories in liquid protein shakes compared to protein bars.

Fortunately, there are diabetic meal replacement bars and diabetes friendly-protein shakes with controlled sugar and calorie content.

I would take the time to read the label of protein bars and ensure that the ingredients are good for you.

"It’s...a good idea to look for a short ingredients list to ensure your bar is minimally processed."

- Ericka Stachura

Protein Powder

If you want the most protein​ in one snack or meal, then protein powder might be your bet.

​A protein shake can have 20-30 grams of protein per serving. Compared to protein bars which are usually 10-15 grams of protein per serving, protein shakes are easily the winner, especially if you're looking to boost your energy for a gym session.

​A disappointment with protein powders and shakes is that it doesn’t give you other vitamins and essential minerals that you can get from eating foods. However, a healthy quick fix for that lack of nutrition would be making protein shakes with fruit and milk.

Protein powders are better than protein bars for people who​se dietary goal is to gain muscle. Protein shakes have ​way more protein amounts ​for every serving. If you give it a go, it will definitely help you get enough protein to build muscle strength. You might want to see our list protein powder for muscle gain.

Which Works Best for Weight Loss?

Protein bars (with generally ​high carb content) work best for weight loss because they give your stomach the impression that you have eaten.

It's something I've noticed in my coaching experience working with different clients One client in particular found that the higher carb content in protein bars helped them feel fuller for longer, aiding in their weight loss journey. This practical insight aligns with the findings from a study by the Obesity Journal that solid foods can be more satiating than liquids [1].

While both protein bars and protein powders can assist with weight loss, it's important to consider their long-term health implications. Frequent consumption of highly processed protein bars or shakes might lead to an imbalance in nutrient intake and potential reliance on supplements over whole foods.

Moderation and a balanced diet should be prioritized for sustainable health.

Which Is Better for Muscle Gain?

muscle gain

Protein powder ​is better for muscle gain. Most of the time, protein shakes contain all nine essential amino acids that are crucial to fuel your fitness.

​These amino acids can ​work to form and build muscles and recover from a fitness routine.

​They also contain way more protein amounts compared to most protein bars.

Unfortunately, not all of them have excellent results so is better to check our comparison guide for protein powders in order to make a wise decision.

When Should I Take Protein?

You should take protein bars in between meals if you are looking to lose weight. If you want to gain muscles and recover from your fitness routine, take protein shakes within two hours of working out for the best results as recommended by experts from the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition [2].

Protein Powder Review: Herbalife's Protein Powder Review


References:

  1. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1038/oby.2010.258
  2. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1186/s12970-017-0189-4
Was this article helpful?
YesNo

About The Author

James Cunningham, BSc, CPT
Staff Writer & Senior Coach
James Cunningham, BSc, CPT holds a BSc degree in Sport & Exercise Science from University of Hertfordshire. He's a Health & Performance Coach from London that brings a unique blend of academic knowledge of health supplements and practical exercise experience to the table for his readers.
Learn more about our editorial policy
Dr. Harshi Dhingra, MBBS, MD is a published peer-reviewed author and renowned physician from India with over a decade of experience. With her MBBS from Bharati Vidyapeeth and an MD from Rajiv Gandhi University, she actively ensures the accuracy of online dietary supplement and medical information by reviewing and fact-checking health publications.
Learn more about our editorial policy
Dr. Kristy June Dayanan, BS, MD is an author with a BS degree from University of the Philippines and an MD from University of Perpetual Help System. Her ability to simplify medical science complexities and dietary supplement jargon for the average reader makes her a valued medical fact checker and reviewer.
Learn more about our editorial policy

You May Also Like

your guide to preworkout and itchiness
By Benedict Ang, CPT, PN1-NC 2 days ago
Why Does Pre-Workout Make You Itch? (How To Prevent It)
A back view of a woman outdoors showing bigger buttocks
By Dr. Harshi Dhingra, MBBS, MD 2 days ago
Can Fish Oil Give You a Bigger Butt? (From a Dietitian)
your guide to creatine and sex drive
By Dr. Harshi Dhingra, MBBS, MD 2 days ago
Can Creatine Help You Sexually? (Benefits & Side Effects)
Your guide to Creatine Kinase test
By Benedict Ang, CPT, PN1-NC 2 days ago
What is Creatine Kinase Test? (How It Can Save Your Life)
your guide to doctor nowzaradan's diet plan
By James Cunningham, BSc, CPT 2 days ago
Dr. Nowzaradan’s Diet Plan - What It Is and Who Is It For?
your guide to preworkout addiction
By Dr. Harshi Dhingra, MBBS, MD 2 days ago
Pre-Workout Addiction - What It Is & How It Happens?

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our scoring system is the result of objective testing data and subjective expert analysis by a team of fitness coaches and medical experts. Our scoring factors are weighted based on importance. For more information, see our product review guidelines.